The Opposition’s Identity Crisis

By Ruwan Laknath Jayakody –OCTOBER 26, 2021

Ruwan Jayakody

With each passing day, the Government seems to be, through its exceedingly consistent capacity for committing political suicide, though not of the honourable harakiri kind (and dragging the hapless country, kicking and screaming, along with it), thanks to its blunderbuss brand of political folly – the latest being the persistent delusion of the efficacy of purchasing more nano nitrogen liquid fertilizer in the face of contrary scientific facts – digging itself into a deep and early grave as far as its political future is concerned. Yet, all is not lost as there is still hope for the Government. It is a fact that voters tend to suffer from cyclical, five yearly bouts of both collective and selective (of political bygones) amnesia when it comes time to cast their Hobson’s choice or exercise their herd insanity by doing the same thing repeatedly in the expectation of different results, in the game of Russian roulette popularly known as the Presidential and General/Parliamentary Elections. While the Government has taken the bull in a China shop route on matters of grave national importance, one is left questioning, whither the de facto alternative Government – the Parliamentary Opposition, and what is the state of affairs of the people’s bulwark against Governmental ineptitude and excess?

Even though American journalist and essayist H.L. Mencken observed that under democracy, one party always devotes its chief energies to trying to prove that the other party is unfit to rule and both commonly succeed, and are right, deconstructing the phenomenon of party politics, Nazi German political theorist Carl Schmitt noted that the equation that politics equals party politics is possible only when antagonisms among domestic political parties succeed in weakening the all embracing political unit which is the State. There is more than a grain of truth in both the views when applied to Sri Lanka. In the context of the commonly held view of Mencken, it can be noted that the policies of both the main Government Parties [(the Sri Lanka Podujana Peramuna (SLPP) and the Sri Lanka Freedom Party (SLFP)] and the main Opposition Party (the Samagi Jana Balawegaya (SJB), the rank and file of which has arisen from the apoptosis of the United National Party (UNP) in the wake of the latter’s festering state of necrosis), constitute, as seen over the years with little variation, a panoply of decrepitude, some of which have gone the way of all flesh, yet are being repackaged as solutions to pressing socio-political-economic concerns. Per Schmitt’s analysis, it can be seen that fissures and fault lines are developing within the ruling nexus of the SLPP-SLFP and also intra-Party within the Opposition (SJB, and the Tamil National Alliance {TNA}), and also in the eyes of the electors, concerning the eternal bride status of the much loved, least voted for Janatha Vimukthi Peramuna (JVP) led National People’s Power (NPP), and the make hay while the sun shines, traditional lack of permanent policies of the All Ceylon Makkal Congress (ACMC) and the Sri Lanka Muslim Congress (SLMC).

The present day Opposition, composed as it is of the SJB, the TNA, the JVP led NPP, the Tamil National People’s Front, the lone pachyderm of the UNP, the Our Power of People’s Party, the ACMC, the SLMC, and a few other minority (ethnic and religious) parties and alliances, is a ragtag band of rag-and-bone men and women, suffering for the most part from an (im)potent admixture of being ideologically challenged and being ideologically possessed, touting a ragbag of lost causes, insincere and vacuous rhetoric, bankrupt objectives, and a farrago of half baked resolutions, and far-fetched or anachronistic solutions. As a Government in waiting, the current Opposition, both as a collective and as individual parties and alliances, occupies even within the wasteland of political detritus, a political demi-monde of sorts.

The factors that have contributed to this state of political dereliction are twofold. The first has to do with the fractious nature of political factionism that is seen within the incumbent Opposition, specifically in the cases of the internecine rivalries within the SJB and the UNP, a situation that is exacerbated in equal measure by pettiness and cattiness, myopia and desultoriness, illusions and delusions, and on the other, the TNA and other Tamil political parties wrestling with the axioms of political moderation and extremity, and the JVP being stuck in an image crisis. The second has to do with the Opposition’s understanding of their democratic function in the context of the political discourse.

With regard to the first issue, whether the Opposition, collective and individually (as parties/alliances), has done enough to find intra and inter party commonality on issues of national interest remains to be seen.

Read More